In an age of platform hype, everyone scrambles to find the platform in their product.
If you’re a product business, chances are you’ve been told that platforms beat products and hence you should look to become a platform.
There is a problem with over-emphasising platform thinking and the ‘platforms beat products’ narrative:
By positioning ‘platforms’ as superior to ‘products’, we risk throwing away the simple first principles of product thinking which have served us well for centuries.
We need to embrace ‘product thinking’ and find the product in our platform.
Understanding the ‘product’ in our platform helps us clarify where it really creates value, and more importantly, where it can effectively capture value.
Through the examples used below, it will also help understand:
Let’s dig in!
Traditional product value chains operate across inputs, product, and distribution.
This simple arrangement creates a linear flow of value to create –what I first called back in 2013 – a ‘pipe’ or a ‘pipeline’.
A product is the offering the firm creates through the transformation of inputs, which it then distributes downstream.
This is fairly straightforward in product value chains.
It gets a lot more vague with platforms.
Platforms combine:
But what is the ‘product’ in the middle in case of platforms.
Essentially, apart from aggregating and organizing producers and consumers – which is largely a mechanism to organize value chain actors – what is the unique product that the platform is creating which gives it the right to sit at the centre of the ecosystem?
If you think of it, distributors and brokers also aggregate producers and consumers. Yet they don’t command the right to sit at the centre of the ecosystem (except through the control of asymmetric information or relationships).
The ‘product’ creates the difference between a distributor and a platform.
What is a platform uniquely creating in the middle which gives it the right to sit at the center of the ecosystem?
Let’s unpack this with a few examples.
If you can accurately identify and explain the product in your platform, you will have a much better handle of your right to play as a platform business.
What does Spotify really ‘produce’?
You might say that Spotify’s product is the music streaming service. But that’s really just a proprietary distribution technology in a product value chain.
You might argue that the products are the songs. But that’s not what Spotify is really producing. The labels own the songs, the artists create them. The songs are inputs into the ‘production’ process.
What exactly is the ‘product’ in Spotify’s platform?
Spotify’s ‘product’ is the playlist.
Playlists are central to Spotify’s strategy within the music ecosystem.
Songs, which were traditionally bundled into albums, were unbundled by the internet and then went through three phases of
This unbundled song distribution changed for the first time with Spotify’s playlists.
Playlists provide the locus of rebundling where songs – unbundled from albums and artists – are rebundled into theme-based playlists.
As WIRED points out:
Playlist placements are highly coveted, both for how they rack up the streams and the way they expose music to new listeners.
Indeed, playlists have become so important that being left off can flop even megastar releases (as Katy Perry discovered after Spotify blackballed her for giving rival Apple Music a temporary exclusive, reminiscent of Amazon cutting off publishers who wouldn’t give it big enough discounts).
Playlists are the core product driving discovery of new artists. They are critical for Spotify to gain a right to sit in the middle of the music value chain and not be merely a digital distributor for the top 3 music labels.
What Spotify ‘sells’ to advertisers and brands is influence and targeting through playlists.
The playlist – the central locus of rebundling in the music streaming business – is Spotify’s core product.
Spotify takes songs/tracks as ‘inputs’, rebundles them into playlists as ‘product’, and sends them down its proprietary streaming ‘distribution’ channel.
And all of this helps Spotify gain power back from the labels.
Without the playlist, Spotify is merely a glorified distributor in the music value chain. A scaled out one, no doubt, but at the end of it all, just a glorified distributor dependant on the whims and fancies of a highly concentrated supplier base constituting three music labels.
The playlist is the ‘product’ that gives Spotify the right to be a platform.
What’s the ‘product’ in Airbnb’s platform?
In high-risk markets like short-term accommodation, trust is unbundled and dispersed across market transactions. Establishing trust requires peer-to-peer tools without central mediation. This may involve
Platforms step in to rebundle trust, which is otherwise embedded in these personal relationships.
In doing so, the platform creates its core product – a mechanism for imputing trust into market transactions.
Instead of relying on fragmented, individual trust-building processes, the platform ‘produces’ a centralized market-wide ‘product’ for establishing and verifying trust.
Airbnb’s ‘product’ – the real value driver for which it can charge a premium on market activity – is its reputation system.
The reputation system is built off explicit inputs like user ratings and implicit signals like cancellation rates after check-in. It manifests explicitly in the form of a five star rating on the interface and implicitly in the exposure/ranking that a listing gets in search results.
The reputation system is the product created at the point of rebundling.
Users pay a premium for the assurance and reliability provided by this ‘product’. Users can engage in transactions with a higher degree of certainty, knowing that trust is not scattered but centralized and managed through the platform’s infrastructure.
What exactly are we talking about here?
The ‘product’ within a platform is created at the point of rebundling.
As digital technologies drive organizations and markets towards unbundling, platforms create value not just through mere integration and aggregation…
…but through rebundling.
This is why vertical marketplaces repeatedly attack Ebay and Craigslist. Horizontal marketplaces win through mere integration and aggregation but they remain vulnerable to attack from a player that doesn’t just aggregate vertical inventory but also creates a superior vertical ‘product’ to organize that market.
What creates a compelling ‘product’ on your platform?
A platform’s goal is to create an efficient market by reducing transaction costs. The ‘product’ in your platform is the unique innovation you provide to solve that problem.
A platform business is not just an open organizational infrastructure but a space where rebundling creates new value. The platforms that win are best able to create relevant products at the point of rebundling.
In fact, let’s clarify this with a few more examples.
Rethinking growth and go-to-market in the age of AI Rapid improvements in AI create new…
How to create new industries ground-up Why is SpaceX more agile and successful than NASA…
The subtle lies of bundling convenience with extraction Today’s platform economy - mediated by the likes of…
How AI Agents and Open APIs create new rebundling opportunities Much of the AI hype…
Gaining power in concentrated markets What do Spotify, the connected vehicle data market, open banking…
The unbundling and rebundling of organizations We frequently make the mistake of thinking of AI…